Uncertain Talks: Um Sam An Seeks Pardons and Security Guarantees Before Possible Phnom Penh Meeting
Former opposition lawmaker Um Sam An has proposed talks in Phnom Penh in early November, but only if charges are dropped, pardons are granted and written security guarantees are provided. The government has not yet responded to his conditions.
Former opposition lawmaker Um Sam An has responded to Prime Minister Hun Manet's invitation with a counterproposal: talks in Phnom Penh during the first week of November. His reply follows a series of public exchanges in which Manet asked him to back up his claims about temporary border markers placed between boundary pillars 52 and 59.
In a letter dated October 12, which Sam An signed and former opposition leader Sam Rainsy later made public, Sam An stressed the need to find solutions to the ongoing Cambodia-Thailand border disputes. He also set out several conditions. He asked that criminal charges against members of a possible delegation be dropped, that pardons be granted, and that the government provide written security guarantees.
Writing as head of his group's National Sovereignty and Border Affairs body, Sam An said he could not decide on taking part in talks alone. He said his group, the Independent Cambodian Government of 23 October, would have to make a collective decision. He did not name any possible delegation members.
Proposed agenda
Sam An wants any public discussions to cover three main topics, not just the boundary pillars 52 to 59 issue raised in Manet's original invitation:
- Cambodia-Thailand land boundary disputes as a whole.
- Maritime boundary disputes between the two countries.
- A request that the Cambodian government ask the French government for technical experts and maps to verify the boundary and pin down its exact position on the ground, based on cartographic evidence.
According to Sam An, the broader agenda is meant to give a full picture of border issues rather than focus only on a border fence he says Thailand built unilaterally between pillars 52 and 59. He suggested holding the talks between November 1 and 7, 2026, with further meetings afterward to work toward lasting solutions. He insisted that his aim is not a political victory or personal attacks, but progress on Cambodia's territorial disputes.
The government's offer
Manet had invited Sam An and his team to present their documents and evidence to officials from the State Secretariat of Border Affairs. Sam An has alleged that the temporary markers resulted in territorial losses for Cambodia in favour of Thailand. Manet rejected that claim but promised to guarantee the safety of Sam An and his team for the duration of their stay. He also offered to pay for airfares, transport and accommodation if Sam An could not afford the trip.
Sam An had raised concerns about his safety and suggested holding the discussions abroad. Manet, however, said the meeting should take place in Cambodia so that officials could verify the disputed locations on site if the document review did not produce a clear result. If Sam An still doubted the government's assurances, Manet added, he could ask a foreign embassy or a trusted Cambodian civil society organisation to monitor his security.
Sam An's latest demands for dropped charges, pardons and written security guarantees go well beyond the public assurances Manet has given.
Context
Border issues between Cambodia and Thailand remain politically sensitive, and negotiations to resolve outstanding disputes are still ongoing. Claims of territorial loss or boundary violations must be tested against legal documents, maps and technical data. Experts also stress that temporary markers placed for technical purposes should not be confused with the formal demarcation of an international boundary, since doing so could lead to false conclusions about changes in sovereignty or territory.
As of publication, the government had not responded to Sam An's latest requests.