Senate Court Lets Prosecutors Drop Three of Four Articles Against VP Sara Duterte
The Senate impeachment court has allowed prosecutors to drop three of the four articles against Vice President Sara Duterte, leaving only the unexplained wealth allegations for trial. The defense has warned the move could undermine due process.
The Senate impeachment court on Tuesday approved a request from the House prosecution panel to withdraw three of the four articles of impeachment against Vice President Sara Duterte. Only the allegations of unexplained wealth and failure to disclose assets remain as the basis for the trial, after 38 days of proceedings.
Presiding officer Francis "Chiz" Escudero accepted the withdrawal of Articles 1, 3 and 4, which lead prosecutor Gerville Luistro, a representative from Batangas, announced on behalf of the panel. The dropped articles covered alleged misuse of confidential funds, bribery, an alleged assassination plot, grave threats, and incitement to sedition. Article 2, which remains, accuses Duterte of amassing unexplained wealth, leaving her statements of assets, liabilities and net worth incomplete, and failing to divest from business interests.
Prosecution stands by its financial case
Luistro said the prosecution considered its evidence on Article 2 strong enough to justify removing Duterte for culpable violation of the Constitution and betrayal of public trust. She argued that focusing on that single article was the most sensible approach given the evidence and the panel's responsibility to the country.
The decision followed the testimony of forensic financial analyst Alexander Cabrera, the prosecution's last witness, who told the court that Duterte's unexplained wealth could reach P1.5 billion.
Defense warns of unfair process
Lead defense counsel Sheila Sison said the withdrawal could deny Duterte a fair chance to respond to evidence that has already been made public. She warned that if the move was meant to speed up the case and move straight to a verdict, the process could amount to a mistrial.
Sison argued that prosecutors should not be able to decide, after evidence has been presented, which accusations the defense must answer. She also said the defense would continue presenting its evidence regardless of the prosecution's choice, since the decision would not change its strategy.
Different conditions for each dropped article
Escudero set different terms for the withdrawn articles. Articles 1 and 4, where evidence had already been presented, were dismissed with prejudice, meaning they cannot be revived or refiled against Duterte during the 20th Congress. Article 3, dropped before any evidence was introduced, was withdrawn without prejudice, but it cannot be brought back in the current trial.
No vote or verdict will be issued on the three dropped articles, and Duterte will not have to defend against them with evidence. Materials linked to those charges will stay in Senate custody under access controls, privacy protections and watermarking rules.
Debate over public comments
Escudero lifted the sub judice restrictions under Rule 18 for the three withdrawn articles, which lets the parties, Duterte included, speak publicly about those allegations. The gag rules still apply to Article 2. He said Duterte should be able to respond and defend her reputation outside the courtroom, since she no longer has to answer those charges as evidence in the trial.
The ruling does not allow unlimited release of evidence. Confidentiality duties, protective orders, legal privileges, statutory secrecy rules and witness protection measures remain in effect.
Senator-judge Pia Cayetano objected to lifting the restrictions while the court was still weighing a reconsideration. She said keeping the existing rules in place would be fairer until both sides had a chance to state their positions. Escudero said he did not want Duterte barred from answering the allegations inside or outside the courtroom. Senator-judge Francis "Kiko" Pangilinan then moved to reconsider the lifting of the restrictions. Escudero deferred a decision until the defense clarified Duterte's position, which could happen within the week.
The defense spokesperson, Michael Poa, cautioned that a gag order issued by a regional trial court in a separate grave threats case could stop Duterte's camp from discussing the allegations under Article 4. Escudero suggested the court could set different restrictions for each article instead of treating all three the same. "It does not have to be all or nothing," he said.
Opposition criticism
Senate Minority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano compared the withdrawal to a fistfight in which one side lands a punch and then tells the other not to strike back. He argued that the prosecution could have focused on the unexplained wealth claims from the start rather than presenting the other charges first.
He also questioned how the defense could meaningfully answer the dropped charges through press conferences or social media livestreams when it has no power to compel witnesses to appear. He stressed that impeachment carries political and reputational consequences, and that fairness and due process should come before a rushed conclusion. The Constitution sets no deadline for finishing an impeachment trial, he noted. He also pointed to the Senate's heavy workload, including deliberations on the proposed 2027 national budget, concerns about a looming super El Niño, unfinished flood control projects and the state of the economy.
Dispute over the word "persecution"
The hearing also saw a clash between Luistro and Sison over the defense's repeated use of the word "persecution." Sison used the term while discussing the scheduled resumption of hearings on November 9. Luistro asked that it be struck from the record, saying it was unfair to volunteer lawyers who had left their private practices to help the prosecution, and that the defense was ignoring courtroom decorum.
Sison said the word came from Duterte's written answer to the impeachment complaint, which described the proceedings as "modern-day persecution." Escudero rejected the prosecution's motion, ruling that the term reflected the respondent's view of the complaint and was not, on its own, an improper attack on the prosecution.