UN Rights Envoy Urges Cambodia to Free Detained Activists Before Francophonie Summit
UN special rapporteur Tom Andrews has urged Cambodia to release people he says were detained for exercising their rights to free expression, assembly and association, ahead of the Francophonie Summit in Phnom Penh. Cambodian officials maintain the cases involve criminal law, not press freedom.
UN special rapporteur on human rights in Cambodia Tom Andrews is calling on the government to release people he says were detained for exercising their rights to free expression, assembly and association. He made the appeal ahead of the 20th Francophonie Summit, which Phnom Penh will host on November 15 and 16.
In a statement issued on November 9, Andrews urged leaders attending the summit to work with Cambodian authorities to secure the release of those he considers wrongfully held. He argued that freeing people jailed for using their fundamental freedoms would honour the values of the International Organisation of La Francophonie (OIF) far more convincingly than any declaration.
Andrews noted that promoting peace, democracy and human rights is central to the organisation's mission, and said the summit gives member states a chance to use their influence on Cambodia's rights record. The event is expected to draw many heads of state and senior ministers, including French President Emmanuel Macron. Cambodia has presented its hosting of the gathering as proof of its continued commitment to Francophone ideals. Andrews suggested the country could also use the occasion to showcase its cultural heritage, its achievements and its record of multilateral cooperation.
He said he has begun reviewing reports of arbitrary arrests and detentions in Cambodia, and believes more than 100 people may be imprisoned for exercising those same rights. Nobody, he stressed, should be detained for defending human rights, reporting on matters of public interest or voicing critical opinions.
Andrews also cited a finding by the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention. The group concluded that the continued detention of Cambodian-American lawyer Seng Theary, former Khmer Student Intellectual League Association president Koet Saray and five activists from Mother Nature Cambodia is arbitrary and violates Cambodia's obligations under international human rights law.
His recent report to the UN Human Rights Council raised further concerns, including restrictions on civic space, alleged harassment of opposition members, online scam networks, the treatment of human trafficking victims, and the plight of Cambodians displaced by the border conflict with Thailand.
Andrews added that if OIF members engage constructively with Cambodia and help secure the release of those unjustly detained, it would demonstrate both the values and the potential of the Francophonie.
Pa Ponnarada, spokesperson for the Cambodian Human Rights Committee (CHRC), responded that Andrews' concerns about the activists are not new, as he had already raised them in a recent address at the UN. Ponnarada argued that the legal action against these individuals should not be viewed as a restriction on press freedom, freedom of speech or freedom of assembly. He pointed out that Cambodia protects these rights under Article 41 of its constitution and has ratified eight conventions and treaties, including the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR).
Citing the third paragraph of Article 19 of the ICCPR, Ponnarada said press freedom cannot be exercised in ways that undermine the rights of others, their dignity, national security, or a country's culture and traditions. When conduct crosses that line, he said, it becomes a crime under Cambodia's criminal code and criminal procedure code. While the UN rapporteur is free to request releases, he argued, the state has the right to enforce its own laws.
Ponnarada said enforcement is meant to uphold the rule of law and protect people affected by those who exceed the limits the law sets on their rights. He encouraged those involved to defend themselves through the courts.