UN Chief Warns Against Appeasement as ASEAN Weighs Re-engaging Myanmar
ASEAN is considering a conditional, step-by-step return of Myanmar’s political representation, while UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres warns that engagement must not excuse violence or weaken accountability. Analysts say Singapore, the next chair, will face the task of turning the decision into real progress.
UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has described Myanmar’s worsening humanitarian emergency as unbearable. He insisted that the violence and abuses must stop, even as ASEAN considers gradually restoring the country’s political standing at its high-level meetings.
Speaking to reporters on the sidelines of the ASEAN Summit in Manila on November 16, Guterres said more than 16 million people in Myanmar need humanitarian aid and over four million have been forced from their homes. He added that airstrikes have become the leading cause of civilian deaths in the country.
At one of his last major diplomatic appearances before his term ends in December, he said a severe humanitarian crisis is still unfolding in Myanmar. Violence must stop, impunity must end, and aid must reach people who need it right away and without conditions, regardless of who controls the territory.
His comments followed a decision by Southeast Asian leaders to take a measured approach to restoring Myanmar’s political representation. That restoration would depend on steady progress toward ending the violence and carrying out the Five-Point Consensus (5PC). Myanmar has been barred from sending political representatives to ASEAN summits and foreign ministers’ meetings since the military seized power in 2021. The country has a population of roughly 51.3 million.
ASEAN drew up the 5PC in April 2021. Among other things, it calls for an immediate end to violence and the start of constructive dialogue among all parties, with ASEAN offering mediation and humanitarian assistance.
Asked whether the bloc’s new stance could break a five-year diplomatic deadlock, Guterres warned that engaging Myanmar’s military-backed leadership must not come at the expense of accountability. “Engagement is not appeasement,” he said.
He stressed that rights abuses must end, humanitarian access must be granted, and people who have been arbitrarily detained must be released.
A measured, step-by-step approach
On November 15, Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said ASEAN leaders had agreed to a “calibrated, step-by-step, progress-based” approach to restoring Myanmar’s political representation. The first test, she said, is whether Myanmar can show progress on the 5PC, especially its demand for an end to violence. “There are still bombings and people being displaced in Myanmar,” she told reporters.
The latest decision is an attempt to reconcile members who want deeper engagement with those who are reluctant to make concessions to the country’s military-backed leadership.
Analysts, however, warned against restoring political representation too soon, before meaningful progress is visible on the ground. Simon Tay, chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, told The Straits Times that political acceptance should follow progress, not come before it. Granting Myanmar full political participation without securing concessions, he argued, would mean giving away one of ASEAN’s few remaining bargaining chips.
On November 15, Singapore Prime Minister Lawrence Wong told fellow leaders that Myanmar’s eventual full return to ASEAN summits must be matched by tangible gains in humanitarian aid, dialogue and violence reduction. He acknowledged that not all violence is under the government’s control, since some attacks are carried out by ethnic armed groups, but said Myanmar’s forces must refrain from violence themselves. “We also want to make sure that there should not be any violence committed by the Myanmar government,” Wong said.
A compromise amid divisions
ASEAN members have been split over how far to engage Myanmar’s military-backed leadership. Thailand has pushed for its foreign minister to be allowed to attend high-level ASEAN meetings. The Manila decision seeks a middle ground. It keeps the restrictions in place while opening a conditional path back to political participation. It also encourages individual members to pursue constructive engagement with relevant stakeholders, in consultation with the ASEAN chair.
Moe Thuzar, senior fellow and coordinator of the Myanmar Studies Programme at the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore, called the decision a diplomatic compromise rather than a fundamental rethink. “ASEAN decisions are the product of negotiated compromise, which is presented as consensus once an agreed position has been reached,” she told The Straits Times.
She said the current position balances continuity in ASEAN’s collective stance with the different approaches taken by individual member states.
Tay said warmer bilateral ties with Myanmar would not automatically change ASEAN’s collective position, which still requires consensus. “There is room for both a good cop and a bad cop within ASEAN, as long as these different approaches stay within the 5PC framework. Otherwise, Myanmar could play one against the other,” he said.
Thuzar noted that engaging different parties in Myanmar is not a new strategy. It has long been part of ASEAN’s efforts to facilitate inclusive dialogue. She pointed to ISEAS’ annual State of Southeast Asia survey, which has consistently found that engaging all stakeholders to build trust is the region’s most preferred approach to the crisis.
Guterres said the UN has never opposed engaging parties to the conflict, noting that its special envoy, Julie Bishop, has maintained contact with different stakeholders. He said the envoy will keep working with ASEAN to find a path toward ending the violence and enabling inclusive dialogue.
Singapore inherits the challenge
The Manila decision places greater emphasis on continuity between successive ASEAN chairs, including further discussions on appointing a longer-term special envoy for Myanmar. Under the current system, the envoy is appointed for each annual chairmanship.
The Philippines, through Lazaro, who also serves as ASEAN’s special envoy on Myanmar, has pursued diplomatic engagement and humanitarian initiatives. Singapore, which takes over the chairmanship in 2027, will inherit the task of turning the Manila decision into concrete diplomatic progress.
Thuzar said this will require clearer benchmarks for measuring developments in Myanmar, including sustained reductions in violence and better humanitarian access. “A progress-based approach depends on what progress is and how it can be measured,” she said.
Tay proposed three possible benchmarks:
- Securing regular ASEAN access to detained former leader Aung San Suu Kyi and other political prisoners.
- Getting the military-backed government to commit to ending violence in areas it claims to control, including places where it has held elections.
- Prioritising humanitarian aid along the Myanmar-Thailand border.
Tay acknowledged that these interim goals may seem unrealistic, given the apparent rejection of the 5PC by the administration led by Min Aung Hlaing (MAH). Still, he said, ASEAN needs to find a middle path, and the MAH administration needs to show it is committed to making progress.