22.11.2026
Mekong MonitorMekong Monitor

UN Chief Warns Against Appeasement as ASEAN Considers Re-engaging Myanmar

UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres called Myanmar’s humanitarian crisis “intolerable” as ASEAN considers a phased return of the country’s political representation. He stressed that engagement must not become appeasement and that violence and abuses must end.

UN Chief Warns Against Appeasement as ASEAN Considers Re-engaging Myanmar

MANILA – UN Secretary-General Antonio Guterres has described Myanmar’s deteriorating humanitarian situation as “intolerable” and insisted that the violence and rights abuses must stop, even as ASEAN weighs a gradual return of the country’s political representation at its high-level meetings.

Guterres said more than 16 million people in Myanmar need humanitarian assistance and over four million have been forced from their homes. Speaking to reporters on the sidelines of the ASEAN Summit in Manila on November 16, he noted that airstrikes have become the leading cause of civilian deaths in the country. It was one of his last major diplomatic appearances before his term ends in December.

“A horrific humanitarian crisis is still playing out in Myanmar,” he said. “The killing must stop. Impunity must end. Aid must reach people in need, wherever they are, immediately and without conditions.”

His comments followed an agreement among Southeast Asian leaders to take a measured approach to bringing back Myanmar’s political representation, but only if there is steady progress toward ending the fighting and carrying out the Five-Point Consensus (5PC). Myanmar has been excluded from sending political representatives to ASEAN summits and foreign ministers’ meetings since the military seized power in the country of roughly 51.3 million people in 2021.

ASEAN introduced the 5PC in April 2021. It calls for an immediate halt to violence and the start of constructive dialogue among all sides, with ASEAN offering mediation and humanitarian help.

Asked whether the bloc’s new stance could break the five-year diplomatic impasse, Guterres warned that engaging Myanmar’s military-backed leadership must not come at the cost of accountability. “Engagement is not appeasement,” he said. He added that abuses must end, aid access must be opened, and people held arbitrarily must be freed.

A calibrated, step-by-step approach

On November 15, Philippine Foreign Secretary Ma. Theresa Lazaro said ASEAN leaders had agreed to a “calibrated engagement” approach that moves step by step and depends on progress in restoring Myanmar’s political representation. The first test, she said, is whether Myanmar can show progress on the 5PC, particularly on ending violence. “There are still bombings and people being displaced in Myanmar,” she told reporters.

The new position is an effort to bridge members who want more engagement and those reluctant to offer any concessions to the military-backed leadership.

Analysts, however, cautioned against restoring political representation before real progress on the ground. Simon Tay, chairman of the Singapore Institute of International Affairs, said recognition should follow progress rather than come first. Restoring full political participation without concessions, he argued, would mean giving up one of ASEAN’s few remaining bargaining tools.

Singapore’s Prime Minister Lawrence Wong told fellow leaders on November 15 that Myanmar’s eventual full return to ASEAN summits should be matched by tangible gains in humanitarian access, dialogue and reduced violence. He acknowledged that not all fighting is under the government’s control, since ethnic armed groups also carry out attacks, but said government forces must refrain from violence. “We also want to make sure there is no violence committed by the Myanmar government,” Wong said.

A compromise amid divisions

ASEAN members have been split over how far to engage Myanmar’s military-led government. Thailand has pushed for its foreign minister to be allowed to attend high-level ASEAN meetings. The Manila decision seeks a middle path: restrictions stay in place, but a conditional route toward restoring political participation is opened.

It also encourages individual members to pursue constructive engagement with relevant parties, in coordination with the ASEAN chair.

Moe Thuzar, senior fellow and coordinator of the Myanmar Studies Programme at the ISEAS – Yusof Ishak Institute in Singapore, described the decision as a negotiated compromise rather than a fundamental shift. “ASEAN decisions are the result of negotiation, and once a position is agreed, it is presented as consensus,” she said. She added that the stance keeps ASEAN’s collective position consistent while allowing individual states to take different approaches.

Tay made a similar point: warmer bilateral ties with Myanmar do not automatically alter ASEAN’s collective stance, which still requires consensus. “ASEAN can accommodate a good cop and a bad cop, as long as both stay within the 5PC framework. Otherwise, Myanmar could play one off against the other,” he said.

Thuzar noted that engaging all parties in Myanmar is not new and has long been central to ASEAN’s push for inclusive dialogue. She cited ISEAS’ annual State of Southeast Asia survey, which has consistently found that engaging all stakeholders to build trust is the region’s preferred approach to the crisis.

Guterres said the UN has never opposed talking to parties involved in the conflict, pointing out that its special envoy, Julie Bishop, has kept in contact with various stakeholders. He said the envoy would keep working with ASEAN to find a route to ending the violence and enabling inclusive dialogue.

Singapore inherits the challenge

The Manila decision puts more weight on continuity between successive ASEAN chairs, including discussions on appointing a longer-term special envoy for Myanmar. At present, the envoy is named each year under the rotating chairmanship. The Philippines has pursued diplomacy and humanitarian initiatives under Lazaro, who also serves as ASEAN’s special envoy on Myanmar.

Singapore takes over the chairmanship in 2027 and will be responsible for turning the Manila decision into real diplomatic progress.

Thuzar said this will require clearer benchmarks to measure change in Myanmar, such as lasting drops in violence and better humanitarian access. “A progress-based approach depends on being able to define and measure progress,” she said.

Tay suggested three possible benchmarks: regular ASEAN access to detained former leader Aung San Suu Kyi and other political prisoners; a commitment from the military-backed government to stop violence in areas it claims to control and where it has held elections; and priority for humanitarian aid along the Myanmar-Thailand border.

He conceded these interim goals may seem unrealistic given the attitude of the Min Aung Hlaing (MAH) administration, which appears to reject the 5PC entirely. “But ASEAN needs to find a middle path, and the MAH administration needs to show it is committed to making progress,” he said.

MyanmarASEANAntonio GuterresFive-Point ConsensusHumanitarian crisis
← Home