Trump's Midterm Setback Offers Little Relief for Southeast Asian Exporters
Democrats' midterm victory may add pressure on President Trump, but analysts say it offers little relief to Southeast Asian exporters facing US tariffs. Trump's broad authority over trade remains largely intact.
Democrats' decisive win in both chambers of the US Congress in last week's midterm elections has dealt a setback to President Donald Trump. It has also raised a question across Southeast Asia: could Washington ease its trade stance toward the region?
Analysts see little chance that lawmakers will be able to curb Trump's tariff agenda. The new balance of power could make it harder for him to push his priorities through over the next two years, but the broader effects on trade and foreign policy remain unclear.
Deborah Elms, head of trade policy at the Asia-based Hinrich Foundation, said the shift may matter less than many expect. "He is a firm believer in tariffs. He thinks they will bring manufacturing jobs back to the United States," she said.
In an interview on Thursday, Elms warned that Trump, who faces criticism at home, could dig in on trade over the coming two years. That is especially likely if congressional opposition stalls his domestic agenda or investigations add pressure on his administration.
Veto power keeps Trump's options open
Trump can still veto any bill Congress passes. Because Democrats lack a two-thirds majority in either chamber, they cannot override a veto, which makes it hard to pass legislation that would strip him of his tariff powers.
Party lines on trade are not clear-cut, either. Some Democrats support protectionist measures too, though they differ with Trump over which countries or industries should be targeted.
Elms added that tariffs are central to Trump's political identity. She doubts enough Republicans will break with him, or that he would accept anything short of a veto-proof outcome.
Tariffs after the Supreme Court ruling
Trump's tariffs unsettled global markets last year, when he imposed "reciprocal" duties of 10 to 50 percent on roughly 90 countries to shrink the US trade deficit. In February, the US Supreme Court ruled that emergency powers could not justify the so-called "Liberation Day" levies. Washington then introduced a temporary global tariff and later announced duties of 10 to 12.5 percent on about 60 trading partners under Section 301. Those duties accuse the partners of failing to stop imports made with forced labor, and they do not require a vote in Congress.
Stephen Olson, a visiting fellow at the Singapore-based ISEAS-Yusof Ishak Institute, wrote in an analysis published on November 1 that the midterm results would give Southeast Asian exporters only limited relief. Congress could push for exemptions and carve-outs, he said, but it is unlikely to halt new tariffs or reverse the administration's wider trade agenda. Any deeper shift in US trade policy, he added, will probably have to wait for the 2028 presidential election.
A possible softening, and a bigger worry
Joshua Kurlantzick, a senior fellow for Southeast Asia and South Asia at the Council on Foreign Relations, sees some potential for the midterms to soften the White House's approach. Voter opposition is growing as more Americans link import duties to higher prices, and Republican lawmakers face more pressure to distance themselves from the policy.
Trump's weakened position at home, Kurlantzick said in an interview on Thursday, means Republicans in Congress, including longtime critics of tariffs, will feel much freer to speak their minds. He was more concerned, however, that Trump could restart the war with Iran, which would have major consequences for Asia.
Energy and cost pressures
Southeast Asia relies heavily on energy shipments from the Gulf, so the conflict poses growing economic risks. Iran closed the Strait of Hormuz in response to US and Israeli strikes, disrupting a vital shipping route. That has threatened oil and gas supplies and raised energy and freight costs, which in turn are feeding into food and commodity prices across the region.
Indonesia is a net oil importer that buys roughly 1 million barrels of crude a day. The disruption has added pressure to its import bill and its foreign exchange reserves.
Limits on Congress's oversight of foreign policy
Pieter Pandie, a researcher at the Jakarta-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies (CSIS), said Democratic control of Congress could bring stronger oversight of Trump's foreign policy and tighter constraints on it. How far that goes, he said in an interview on Friday, is still uncertain. Newly elected members will not take office until next year, so the consequences will take time to emerge.
The result is a setback for Trump, whose Republican Party had controlled both chambers. It gives Democrats more room to scrutinize and check the administration's foreign policy. Pandie cautioned, however, that this does not automatically reduce the president's discretion. Trump can still act without prior congressional approval, and any legislation seeking to limit his policies can be blocked with a veto.
For Indonesia, Pandie said, the key things to watch are Washington's approach to the Middle East and the Indo-Pacific, particularly its relationship with China.
Trump's upcoming regional trip
Trump is scheduled to make his first overseas trip since the midterms in mid-November. He will travel to Manila for the ASEAN summit, then to China for the APEC summit in Shenzhen. Analysts say these visits will give Southeast Asian governments an early signal of how the administration plans to manage its regional relationships after the electoral setback.
Elms expects the administration to push for faster implementation of existing trade agreements at those meetings, including the Agreement on Reciprocal Trade (ART) with Indonesia. However, the White House has not yet worked out how it would speed up implementation, and it still needs more time to settle its position.