Three Years After October 7: How a Date Became a Cover for Genocide
Three years after 7 October 2023, a single date is still being used to justify and shut down debate about the devastation in Gaza. This opinion piece examines the self-defence claims, the legal arguments and the wider erosion of international law.
Three years on, the suffering has not stopped. A calendar date, 7 October 2023, has been asked to carry a weight no date can bear. It has been used to justify, excuse and shut down debate about everything that followed. Palestinians in Gaza have paid for this reasoning with their lives, their homes and their future. The central questions since then have been what has been done in that name, and whose experience has been left out of the story.
The figures are difficult to absorb. Gaza’s Ministry of Health reports at least 74,016 Palestinians killed and 175,068 wounded since October 2023. Women and children make up about half of the dead, and 1,145 people have been killed since the ceasefire took effect in October 2025. Each number stands for a person: a child, a nurse, a teacher, a grandmother, and often a grieving family that may itself have been wiped out.
The harm goes well beyond death. Around 90 per cent of Gaza’s population has been forced from their homes, many of them more than once. The UN Environment Programme found that 78 per cent of the territory’s roughly 250,000 buildings have been damaged or destroyed. Hospitals, schools, bakeries, sewage and water systems, and universities have all been hit. In 2025, the global hunger monitor declared famine in parts of Gaza.
If a single date can explain all of this, we need to ask what kind of explanation it really is.
In the days after 7 October, Israeli leaders set out a new approach. The goal was no longer to respond to a specific threat, but to dismantle an entire system of governance and much of civilian life in Gaza. Officials used dehumanising language, including the phrase “human animals”. A total siege was announced, cutting off food, fuel, water and electricity.
The Fourth Geneva Convention prohibits the collective punishment of civilians, and it also bans starving civilians as a method of warfare. Israel’s policies, however, treated these prohibitions as obstacles to be explained away rather than limits to be respected.
The Language of Self-Defence
The main tool was the language of self-defence. States do have a right to defend themselves, but that right comes with conditions. Force must be necessary and proportionate, it must be aimed at military targets, and civilians must be protected. It is also far from settled that a state can claim self-defence against territory it occupies and controls. In its 2024 advisory opinion on Israel’s presence in the occupied Palestinian territory, the International Court of Justice found that presence unlawful and said it must end.
Still, “self-defence” became a phrase that closed conversations rather than opened them. Every strike, evacuation order and blocked aid convoy could be placed under its umbrella. In Western media, the more often the term was repeated, the less anyone asked whether its conditions were actually being met.
Three Tools Behind the Narrative
Three tools in particular shaped how the world came to understand events.
The first is the “human shield” argument. Israel places the blame for civilian deaths on the other side. International law does not work that way. Even when fighters operate near civilians, especially in a densely populated place like Gaza, the attacking side must still distinguish between military targets and civilians, and must weigh the expected harm to civilians against the anticipated military gain. Saying civilians were in the way does not cancel the duty not to kill them en masse. Israeli forces describe civilian deaths as collateral damage while claiming to target “militants”, but the argument here is that civilians themselves have been deliberately targeted. The killing of six-year-old Hind Rajab, who sat defenceless in a car reportedly hit by at least 335 bullets, raises serious questions about how civilians, including children, have been treated during Israeli military operations.
The second is the evacuation order. Residents were told to move south, and then to move again. This was presented as protection for civilians, but it pushed people into shrinking areas with little shelter, food or medicine, and those areas were later struck as well. At times, civilians were hit while they were in the middle of evacuating. For Palestinians, who carry the memory of 1948, when hundreds of thousands were forced from their homes and never allowed back, the fear that displacement might become permanent revived a history that seemed to be repeating itself.
The third is the label. When civilians are described as “militants” or “associated with terror” after Israeli forces have killed them, as has been alleged even in the cases of journalists and aid workers, the label becomes a justification for their deaths. It turns a question of law into a question of identity.
The scale of destruction has also outpaced our existing vocabulary, which is why scholars and UN experts have coined new terms. “Urbicide” describes the erasure of a city, and scholars have used it for Gaza given the extent of the damage. “Educide” refers to the targeting of education. UNICEF says nearly 90 per cent of Gaza’s schools have been damaged or destroyed, more than 700,000 children cannot access formal education, and a UN cultural rights expert reports that every university has been hit. “Ecocide” names the poisoning of land and water. UNEP reports polluted fresh water, destroyed vegetation and rubble that will take decades to clear. “Ethnocide” points to the loss of a people’s culture, including libraries and a central archive holding 150 years of Gaza’s history. Some of these terms are not yet formal legal crimes, and Israel rejects such accusations. But the law already protects schools, cultural property, the environment and children. Taken together, these patterns challenge Israel’s self-defence argument.
Accountability and International Law
International institutions have not been silent, but they have been slow, and often blocked. In January 2024, the International Court of Justice found it plausible that some of the rights South Africa invoked under the Genocide Convention were at risk. It ordered Israel to take steps to prevent acts of genocide and to allow aid in. Israel strongly denies the genocide accusation and says its operations target armed groups, not the Palestinian people. The full case will take years, and the written phase may not finish until 2029. Palestinians in Gaza cannot wait that long, and many will not live to see a ruling.
In November 2024, the International Criminal Court issued arrest warrants for Israel’s prime minister and its former defence minister over alleged war crimes and crimes against humanity. Israel rejects the court’s jurisdiction. In September 2025, a UN Commission of Inquiry concluded that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza, a finding Israel again rejected. A state facing some of the gravest legal accusations in the world has continued its military operations without being held to account. Meanwhile, some of its closest allies have shielded it from consequences, supplied it with weapons and, in some cases, attacked the courts themselves.
This matters well beyond Gaza. International law is only as strong as the willingness to apply it equally. When rules are enforced against some and waived for others, they stop functioning as law and become politics. People have noticed. That is why trust in the so-called rules-based order has fallen so sharply, especially across the Global South.
Where the Story Begins
There is another way 7 October has been used: as the starting point of history. Many news reports and political speeches begin the story on that morning, as if decades of earlier events never happened. Starting in 2023 erases more than seven decades of displacement, military occupation, settlement expansion that international law prohibits, and a blockade of Gaza that has strangled daily life since 2007. It also dismisses the experiences of the people who have lived through all of it since 1948.