Should Young Americans Study in China? Xi's Invitation Revives the Debate Over Risks and Rewards
Chinese President Xi Jinping's offer to bring 100,000 young Americans to China has reopened debate over whether the trips are worth it. Analysts weigh the need for firsthand China expertise against the political risks and the limits on academic freedom.
When American student Josh Lipman started weighing where to spend a semester abroad, he looked at Europe, Australia and parts of Asia, including Japan. China barely registered. “I think that China just isn’t really on people’s radar. I can’t even remember what programmes we have there, to be honest,” said the third-year public policy student at George Washington University, who is 20.
Even if he did consider China, he said, he would have reservations about surveillance and about adjusting to a political system unlike the one he knows. Those concerns would not necessarily rule it out. The details of the programme would matter most. He added that students would likely feel more comfortable with a semester-long exchange run through their own university than with enrolling independently in a full degree at a Chinese university.
“I could see a study abroad experience as being both a positive and a negative. Given the importance of US-China relations to national security, having first-hand experience would maybe be a boost to people,” he said.
His doubts reflect the wider questions raised by Chinese President Xi Jinping’s invitation for 100,000 young Americans to visit China for study and exchanges over the next five years. He made the offer during a state visit to Washington for a closely watched summit with US President Donald Trump. The figure is double the 50,000 target Xi set in 2023. US-China observers are once again arguing over whether sending the next generation of Americans to China to study the world’s most consequential rival is necessary and worthwhile. Xinhua reported that the 50,000 goal was reached in 2026, ahead of schedule.
Some analysts warn that the US could lose a generation of officials, scholars and business leaders who have the firsthand knowledge needed to understand China. The number of Americans studying there has fallen to a small fraction of its pre-pandemic level. Others, including Americans whose careers were built during years in China, question whether the benefits now outweigh the risks students could face in a more restrictive political climate with less academic freedom.
A sharp imbalance in student flows
According to the Open Doors Report on International Educational Exchange, 265,919 Chinese students were enrolled at US institutions in 2024 to 2025. By contrast, only 1,749 American students earned academic credit for studying in China in 2023 to 2024, the most recent year available. That is down from more than 11,600 in 2017 to 2018 and 2018 to 2019. The two figures track different types of student mobility and cannot be compared directly, but together they show how sharply the flow of Americans to China has dropped.
Sun Chenghao, a senior fellow at Tsinghua University’s Center for International Security and Strategy in Beijing, said the imbalance has both political and structural causes. American universities have long drawn Chinese students who come for degrees, research and international careers. Americans who went to China, by contrast, have usually done language training or short exchanges. The Covid-19 pandemic disrupted programmes. Rising geopolitical tensions, worries about research access and personal safety, funding cuts and university restrictions have discouraged others from going.
A 2026 report from the US-China Education Trust points to another deterrent: a “widespread perception” that studying in China could damage a returning American student’s chances of getting a security clearance for government work. Some US government-backed programmes that once helped Americans build China expertise have also been suspended. The Fulbright programme is one example. Its first American scholar, Derk Bodde, arrived in China in 1948 and left a firsthand account of the turbulent end of the Chinese Civil War and the founding of the People’s Republic. Other federally funded efforts to build foreign-language and regional expertise, including the Boren Awards, the Critical Language Scholarship and the National Security Language Initiative for Youth, have also halted programmes in mainland China.
Is firsthand experience worth the risk?
In a Council on Foreign Relations article published on September 23, ahead of the Trump-Xi summit, political scientist Rush Doshi and Rosie Levine, executive director of the US-China Education Trust, argued that Washington needs a much deeper pool of China experts to keep up with a fast-changing relationship. They warned that a country no longer training people who can read Chinese primary sources, sit in Chinese classrooms or track how policies are carried out on the ground is less secure and less capable of understanding and competing with China. They urged both governments to revive exchanges such as Fulbright and to give top-level assurances that participants would not face undue risk from Chinese security services.
Xi made no such public assurances when he issued his invitation, and readouts from both governments did not indicate that the two leaders discussed safeguards for American students.
Isaac Stone Fish, founder and chief executive of Strategy Risks, a firm that assesses companies’ exposure to China, said he values firsthand exposure. However, he argued that tighter control of information and stricter limits on what people can say and do have changed the calculation for students today. He lived in China from 2006 to 2011 and last visited in 2019. “The single best thing that American universities can do is to tell students the truth about the risks of studying in China,” he said. “They should make clear that the space for freedom of speech is more constrained than it is in the US, so American students and their parents can make much more informed decisions.”
What Beijing hopes to gain
Beijing has its own reasons for wanting more young Americans to visit. Kevin Chen, an associate research fellow with the US Programme at the S. Rajaratnam School of International Studies at Nanyang Technological University, described engaging American youth as “low-hanging fruit” for China. Younger Americans are relatively warmer toward China, and visits by American personalities such as the streamer IShowSpeed in 2025 have drawn attention to the country. “In doing so, Beijing likely hopes to nurture a generation of Americans who are more sympathetic to Chinese viewpoints,” Chen said.
Where exchange ends and influence begins has become a point of controversy in the US. In 1985, a 31-year-old Xi visited the small Iowa city of Muscatine as part of an agricultural delegation. Beijing often cites that trip as proof of the value of people-to-people ties.
Nearly 40 years later, in 2024, more than 20 students from Muscatine High School became the first American group to visit China after Xi’s initial invitation for 50,000 young Americans. The school disclosed that the Chinese government fully paid for the trip. Months later, at least one Iowa state lawmaker called for future trips to be cancelled, arguing they could be used for propaganda. Defenders replied that the exchange was educational and transparent.
Chen said American funding, rather than all-expenses-paid trips financed by Beijing, could ease political and security concerns. Even so, he said, recognising Beijing’s soft-power goals does not cancel out the value of an exchange. Students can still learn about the everyday lives of ordinary Chinese people, even while dealing with limits on academic freedom.