Philippine Defense Chief Teodoro Dismisses Beijing's Claim That Manila Misused ASEAN Chairmanship
Philippine Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro Jr. rejected China's claim that Manila misused its ASEAN defense meetings chairmanship to block Beijing's participation. He said the view was Beijing's alone, not the bloc's.
Philippine Defense Secretary Gilberto Teodoro Jr. on Thursday pushed back against China's charge that Manila had misused its role as chair of the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) defense meetings in order to block Beijing from taking part.
Teodoro said the accusation did not represent the views of the regional bloc. He was responding to Chinese Defense Ministry spokesperson Zhang Xiaogang, who had argued that the Philippines was breaking ASEAN's consensus-based principles and undermining China's standing as a dialogue partner.
“As far as ASEAN is concerned, I don't believe our fellow member states feel that way. If they did, they would have told me,” Teodoro said at a press conference in Lapu-Lapu City, Cebu, after the 13th ASEAN Defence Ministers' Meeting-Plus (ADMM-Plus).
“So that is China's position, not ASEAN's,” he said, drawing a clear line between the two.
Beijing's accusation
Zhang had accused Manila of letting “a self-serving politician” act recklessly and exploit the chairmanship of the 13th ADMM-Plus, held on October 28 and 29, to obstruct China's participation. He made the remarks when asked why Beijing had sent its defense attaché rather than its defense minister. In a statement shared by the Chinese Embassy in Manila on Thursday, he said the Philippines had ignored diplomatic protocol and violated ASEAN's principle of consensus through consultation. He also claimed that several ASEAN members had raised questions about, and objected to, Manila's conduct.
Teodoro's response
Teodoro maintained that only ASEAN member states have the right to define how the bloc runs its meetings. “No country other than ASEAN members can characterize ASEAN processes. The dialogue partners are not in that position,” he said. He added that while the Philippines would like to accommodate them, the process is bound by rules and limits.
He stressed that the Chinese representative had been given the chance to present Beijing's views on regional and maritime security. “The key point is that they were able to set out their position on regional and maritime security,” he said. According to Teodoro, the meeting allowed a lively exchange of views among all participants, China included. “How their views are received is for ASEAN itself to decide, not anyone else,” he said.
Asked why he had not met the Chinese attaché personally, Teodoro pointed to the difference in rank between them. “There should be some parity in rank and standing. An undersecretary receiving an attaché is already more than courteous,” he said.
Teodoro also confirmed that China raised the South China Sea during the ADMM-Plus discussions. He declined, however, to give details of what Beijing said or how other countries reacted. He noted that China's position was consistent with its earlier statements on regional security.
The ADMM-Plus brings together ASEAN defense ministers and eight dialogue partners: China, the United States, Japan, Australia, India, South Korea, New Zealand and Russia. The Philippines is hosting these meetings as part of its 2026 ASEAN chairmanship.