Paper Straws Rated Worse Than Plastic on Some Environmental Measures, Korean Study Finds
A South Korean government study finds that paper straws can carry a heavier environmental burden than plastic on certain measures, including modeled carcinogenic impact and acidification.
A government-commissioned study in South Korea has found that paper straws can have a much larger environmental footprint than conventional plastic straws on certain measures. Across their full life cycle, from manufacturing through use and disposal, paper straws scored 6.33 times higher than plastic straws on modeled human carcinogenic impact.
The report was ordered by the Ministry of Climate, Energy and Environment and made public on Wednesday by lawmaker Kim Wi-sang of the People Power Party. It compared four kinds of straws: conventional plastic, paper, biodegradable plastic, and bio-based polyethylene (bio-PE). Researchers tracked each one from raw material production to final disposal across 16 impact categories.
The carcinogenic figure is a modeled estimate of life-cycle impact, not a measure of actual cancer risk for people who use the straws. The calculations assumed that 73.6 percent of discarded straws are incinerated and 26.4 percent end up in landfills, based on national waste data.
Paper straws also showed 2.04 times the acidification impact of plastic straws. Bio-PE fared worse, with 16.18 times the carcinogenic impact and 5.9 times the acidification impact. Biodegradable plastic straws came in at 3.34 times the carcinogenic impact and 1.98 times the acidification impact.
Across the 16 categories, conventional plastic straws had the lowest impact in 10, including climate change, acidification, particulate matter and human toxicity. Bio-PE had the highest impact in 10 categories, including ozone depletion, acidification and smog formation. Paper straws had the highest impact in three categories, and biodegradable plastic in two.
South Korea began restricting plastic straws at cafes and restaurants in November 2022. In November 2023, however, the government indefinitely extended the enforcement grace period after public complaints and doubts about whether the policy was working.
Kim criticized the approach directly. “The government must admit that its greenwashing policy, which focused on ineffective substitute materials, was a failure, and it must not repeat that mistake,” he said. “Policy should focus on reducing the overall use of disposable products.”
Bio-PE is made from renewable plant sources such as sugarcane. Chemically, though, it is identical to conventional polyethylene and does not biodegrade, which sets it apart from biodegradable plastic despite the similar name.
Are alternative straws actually greener?
Paper straws are often marketed as recyclable, but the researchers found that straws made from any of the materials tested are hard to recycle in practice. Their small size makes them difficult for sorting facilities to pick out, and coatings or adhesives can further complicate the process.
The report also included a survey of 1,001 people. Of those surveyed, 87.5 percent said they preferred plastic straws. About 54.4 percent backed providing straws only when customers ask for them, while 18.4 percent opposed that policy.
Based on these findings, the researchers recommended that stores stop offering any disposable straw by default and provide one only on request.