Indonesian Official’s ‘Oxygen Too’ Claim Over Haze Draws Mockery in Malaysia
An Indonesian official’s claim that his country supplies Malaysia and Singapore with oxygen as well as haze has drawn sarcastic criticism from Malaysians online. The remark comes as regional talks over the forest-fire haze continue.
An Indonesian government official has come under fire online after claiming his country supplies Malaysia and Singapore with “oxygen, not just haze.” Social media users in Malaysia responded with sarcasm and open disbelief.
Syahganda Nainggolan, head of Indonesia’s Government Communications Agency, made the remarks while responding to complaints about the transboundary haze caused by ongoing forest fires in Indonesia. According to Indonesian media reports published on Saturday (Oct 10), he said that Indonesia does not only send smoke across the border. When the skies are clear, he argued, the oxygen breathed in Singapore and Malaysia also comes from Indonesia’s forests.
Online backlash
The comment was quickly mocked. Users questioned how anyone could trace oxygen to a single country. Facebook user Richard Wong asked how oxygen from Indonesia could possibly be identified, while Foong Sp pointed out that oxygen is impossible to measure in that way, yet haze is easy to quantify. Others targeted the logic itself. Stanley Yeo asked whether sending oxygen was meant to fuel more fires, and another commenter joked that Indonesia might as well claim credit for the sunshine.
Downplaying human responsibility
Syahganda also played down human involvement in the crisis. Rather than linking the fires to land clearing or negligence, he described them as a natural phenomenon. He asked neighbouring countries to accept that the blazes were a matter of nature rather than human error, and said discussions with Malaysia and Singapore on joint mitigation efforts were still ongoing.
Diplomatic backdrop
The row comes as the regional haze dominates diplomatic exchanges. Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim raised his concerns with Indonesian President Prabowo Subianto on Oct 8. On Oct 10, Singapore’s Sustainability and the Environment Minister, Grace Fu, reaffirmed that the city-state is ready to help with firefighting operations.