Haze Crisis Debate Heats Up Ahead of ASEAN Summit
Indonesia's wildfire haze has triggered a fresh dispute between Jakarta, Kuala Lumpur and Singapore over blame and the role of foreign companies. Analysts are urging the three countries to focus on fighting the fires ahead of the ASEAN summit.
Uncontrolled forest and peatland fires in Indonesia have sparked a fresh war of words between officials and politicians in Jakarta, Kuala Lumpur and Singapore. The dispute centers on who is to blame for the transboundary haze and what role foreign corporations play in it.
For weeks, fires have burned across large parts of Sumatra and Kalimantan during an unusually severe dry season intensified by El Niño. The toxic smoke has drifted into Singapore and Malaysia, turning what began as a domestic disaster into a diplomatic row.
In a speech on Wednesday, President Prabowo Subianto criticized unnamed countries that, in his view, keep insulting Indonesia over the fires. He argued that foreign companies bear responsibility for the crisis and promised to name them at the right time. Speaking at a cabinet meeting held to mark his second year in office, he said Indonesia is a patient nation but will not keep tolerating provocation.
Prabowo, whose approval ratings have fallen to their lowest level ahead of the anniversary, said he had ordered law enforcement agencies to investigate the blazes with help from the military and intelligence services. He described the fires as not purely natural and called deliberate burning a form of environmental terrorism. On Thursday, he said authorities had found signs linking several foreign firms to the fires. He vowed to revoke the permits of any company found to have broken the law and suggested Indonesians could take over management of the affected plantations.
His comments come amid growing criticism at home and abroad of how Jakarta has handled the crisis. Residents affected by the smoke have pressed the government to do more to extinguish the fires, and several politicians in neighboring countries have questioned the response.
Malaysian lawmaker Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman has urged ASEAN members to apply both diplomatic and financial pressure on Indonesia over the recurring haze, and he has called for the country to be treated as a regional outcast. Meanwhile, Singaporean Prime Minister Lawrence Wong and Sustainability and Environment Minister Grace Fu announced last week that they would take firm legal action. They issued preventive measure notices to seven Indonesian companies strongly suspected of being responsible for fire hotspots.
Former trade minister Muhammad Lutfi hit back at Singaporean and Malaysian politicians on social media on Tuesday, arguing that the haze should not be used for political point-scoring. He said companies from both countries that operate plantations in Indonesia should also be held accountable. Presidential Advisory Council member Ignasius Jonan made a similar case in an Instagram video, urging Singapore and Malaysia to work with Indonesia on fighting the fires and punishing the companies responsible.
The row comes as Southeast Asian foreign ministers prepare to discuss the haze at preparatory meetings ahead of the bloc's November summit in Manila. The talks follow Malaysia's call for an urgent regional meeting to address the problem, which keeps recurring.
Blame game won't put out the fires
Recent reports from environmental groups Greenpeace and Walhi have identified companies based in Singapore and Malaysia whose Indonesian subsidiaries or local operations are allegedly linked to fire-affected areas.
Walhi activist Umi Ma'rufah, however, accused Prabowo of focusing on perceived insults from other countries instead of addressing his government's own responsibility for fires that continue to choke Indonesians with toxic smoke.
“Claims of foreign involvement must not become a way for the government to avoid its own responsibility,” Umi told The Jakarta Post. She said authorities must identify everyone responsible, both foreign-owned and domestically owned companies, and ensure they face the consequences under existing laws.
International relations expert Hikmahanto Juwana criticized the back-and-forth accusations among officials. He said Indonesia, Singapore and Malaysia should concentrate on putting out the fires rather than trading arguments that do nothing to stop the burning. “Will these debates put out the fires in Kalimantan and Sumatra? No, they will not,” he said, urging the countries to cooperate under the ASEAN Agreement on Transboundary Haze Pollution.